M. M. Speransky and his Worldview: Touches to the Portrait of a Statesman
Abstract
Relevance. In modern conditions, it seems relevant to consider the history of the formation of Russian legislation. Now the question of the historical roots of liberalism is debatable. The problem of the birth of liberal ideas in Russia now remains without an unambiguous assessment. A study of Speransky's views is necessary to distinguish between Russian and European liberalism. M. Speransky's understanding of the rights and freedoms of citizens is also important for the modern era.
The purpose of this work is to show the difference of Speransky’s views from the European liberal doctrine.
The objectives of the study are to analyze the discussion on the problem of the emergence of liberal ideas in Russia; define Speransky's concept as a doctrine of conservative liberalism; to reveal the humanistic orientation of his concept.
Methodology. The methodological basis of the article is the dialectical method, system analysis, culturological and phenomenological approaches, which make it possible to assess the contribution and significance of Speransky's concept to the development of Russian social thought.
Results. It is shown that M.M. Speransky introduced the humanistic tradition into the system of liberalism. For the first time, Speransky's thoughts about the “Highest Liberty” are presented. Striving for good, truth, perfect law is the basis of human will, they make this Highest Liberty real. This is the origin of Speransky's doctrine of good, which is the theoretical foundation of his concept.
Conclusions. The study established the differences between Russian liberalism and European: 1) defining the humanistic basis of liberalism; 2) The source of the definition of Liberty in the Russian liberal tradition is the “mystical feeling” and the baseless principles of cognition: the search for the “incomprehensible” conditions for the movement of activity from necessity to liberty; 3) defined Russian liberalism as conservative liberalism; 4) Speransky summed up the moral and ethical foundations for the liberal doctrine.
About the Authors
Olga V. KozlovaRussian Federation
Candidate of Philosophical Sciences, Associate Professor of History and Philosophy Department
Chkalova str. 6, Yaroslavl 150054
Dmitrii N. Khristenko
Russian Federation
Candidate of Historical Sciences, Associate Professor of History and Philosophy Department
Chkalova str. 6, Yaroslavl 150054
References
1. Shreider K. I. Rannii russkii liberalizm v otechestvennoi i zarubezhnoi istoriografii [Early Russian liberalism in Russian and foreign historiography]. Rossiiskaya istoriya = Russian history, 2010, no. 4, pp. 177–187.
2. Nikotin A.D. Liberalizm i reformatorstvo v Rossii: Vzaimodeistvie paradigmy i praktiki. Diss. kand. polit. nauk. [Liberalism and Reformism in Russia: Interaction of Paradigm and Practice. Diss. cand. polit. sci.]. Volgograd, 1999. 200 p.
3. Shkurinov P. S. Filosofiya v Rossii XVIII veka [Philosophy in Russia in the 18th century]. Moscow, Vyshaya shkola Publ., 1992. 256 p.
4. Rozov N. S. Natsional'naya ideya kak imperativ razuma [The national idea as an imperative of reason]. Voprosy filosofii = Philosophy questions, 1997, no. 10, pp. 13–28.
5. Masarik T. G. Liberalizm (iz knigi «Rossiya i Evropa») [Liberalism (from the book "Russia and Europe")]. Voprosy filosofii = Philosophy questions, 1997, no. 10, pp. 118–131.
6. Shaskol'skaya E. A. Istoriya Rossii IX–XX vv. [History of Russia IX–XX centuries]. St. Petersburgb, Obrazovanie - kul1'tura Publ., 1995. 370 p.
7. Lantsov S. A. Totalitarizm kak forma modernizatsii Rossii: genezis i rezul'taty [Totalitarianism as a form of Russia's modernization: genesis and results]. Sfinks. Peterburgskii filosofskii zhurnal = Sphinx. Petersburg philosophical journal, 1994, no. 2, pp. 100–117.
8. Klyuchevskii V. O. Russkaya istoriya. Polnyi kurs lektsii v trekh knigakh. Kniga vtoraya. [Russian history. A complete course of lectures in three books. Book two]. Moscow, Mysl' Publ., 1995. 592 p.
9. Leontovich V. V. Istoriya liberalizma v Rossii. 1762–1917 [The history of liberalism in Russia. 1762–1917]. Moscow, Russkii put' Publ., 1995. 445 p.
10. Novikova L. I., Sizemskaya I. N. Ideinye istoki russkogo liberalizma [Ideological origins of Russian liberalism]. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost' = Social sciences and modernity, 1993, no. 3, pp. 124–135.
11. Golikov A. K., Gogotov S. L. Lichnost', sobstvennost', gosudarstvo v sotsial'nofilosofskoi i politicheskoi kontseptsii rannego russkogo liberalizma vtoroi poloviny XIX v. [Personality, property, state in the socio-philosophical and political concept of early Russian liberalism in the second half of the 19th century]. Klio = Clio, 1997, no. 3, pp. 15–23.
12. Zamaleev A. F., Osipov I. D. Russkaya politologiya: obzor osnovnykh napravlenii [Russian political science: an overview of the main directions]. St. Petersburgb, St. Petersburg univ. Publ., 1994. 208 p.
13. Pushkin A. S. Sobr. Soch [Collected works]. Moscow, Hudozh. lit. Publ.1977, vol. X. 443 p.
14. Mezin S. A. Petr I, Leibnits i Speranskii [Leibniz and Speransky]. Rossiiskaya istoriya = Russian History, 2011, no. 1, pp. 115–120.
15. Vorontsov A. G. Zapiska o Rossii nyneshnego veka, predstavlennaya imperatoru Aleksandru Pavlovichu po vstuplenii v dolzhnost' gosudarstvennogo kantslera [Note about Russia of the current century, presented to Emperor Alexander Pavlovich upon assuming the office of
16. State Chancellor]. Arkhiv knyazei Vorontsovykh = Archive of the Vorontsov Princes. Moscow, Tip. A. I. Mamontova, 1883, pp. 451–470.
17. Malinovskii V. F. Razmyshleniya o preobrazhenii gosudarstvennogo ustroistva Rossii [Reflections on the transformation of the state structure of Russia]. Izbrannye obshchestvennopoliticheskie sochineniya [Selected socio-political writings]. Moscow, Acad. sci. Publ., 1958. 170 p.
18. Speranskii M. M. O korennykh zakonakh gosudarstva [On the fundamental laws of the state]. Proekty i zapiski [Projects and notes]. Moscow, Leningrad, Akad. nauk Publ., 1961, pp. 28–55.
19. Dnevnik Et'ena Dyumona ob ego priezde v Rossiyu v 1803 g. [Diary of Etienne Dumont about his arrival in Russia in 1803]. Golos minuvshego = Voice of the past, 1913, no. 4, pp. 124–145.
20. Iz zapisok D. P. Runicha [From the notes of D. P. Runich]. Russkaya starina = Russian Antiquity, 1901, no. 1, pp. 47–77.
21. Speranskiy M. M. Pravila vysshego krasnorechiya [The rules of supreme eloquence]. St. Petersburgb, I. Vetrinskii Publ., 1844. 216 p.
22. Bodriiyar Zh. Fatal'nye strategii [Fatal strategies]. Moscow, Gruppa Kompanii "RIPOL klassik" / "Pangloss", 2019. 319 p.
23. Speranskiy M. M. Eshche nechto o svobode i rabstve [Something else about freedom and slavery]. Proekty i zapiski [Projects and notes]. Moscow, Leningrad, Akad. nauk Publ., 1961, pp. 83–85.
24. Pisar'kova L. F. Nepremennyi ili gosudarstvennyi sovet byl v Rossii v 1801–1809? [An indispensable or state council was in Russia in 1801–1809?]. Rossiiskaya istoriya = Russian History, 2008, no. 5, pp. 128–130.
25. Speranskij M. M. v Penze [In Penza]. Russkaya starina = Russian Antiquity, 1902, vol. 112, is. 10–12, pp. 341–345.
26. Speranskij M. M. Vvedenie k Ulozheniyu gosudarstvennyh zakonov [Introduction to the Code of State laws]. Proekty i zapiski [Drafts and notes]. Moscow, Leningrad, Akad. nauk Publ., 1961, pp. 143–221.26. Razmyshlenie o gosudarstvennom ustrojstve imperii [Reflection on the state structure of the empire]. Proekty i zapiski [Projects and notes]. Moscow, Leningrad, Akad. nauk Publ., 1961, pp. 56–67.
27. Primechaniya o Senate [Notes on the Senate]. Proekty i zapiski [Drafts and notes]. Moscow, Leningrad, Akad. nauk Publ., 1961, pp. 67–75.
28. Hristoforov I. A. Ot Speranskogo do Stolypina: krest'yanskaya reforma i problema zemleustrojstva [From Speransky to Stolypin: peasant reform and the problem of land management]. Rossijskaya istoriya = Russian History, 2011, no. 4, pp. 27–43
29. Speranskij M. M. Volya [Volition]. V pamyat' grafa Mihaila Mihajlovicha Speranskogo. 1772–1878 [In memory of Count Mikhail Mikhailovich Speransky. 1772–1878]. St. Petersburg, Izd. Imperatorskoj publichnoj b-ki, 1872, pp. 779–790.
Review
For citations:
Kozlova O.V., Khristenko D.N. M. M. Speransky and his Worldview: Touches to the Portrait of a Statesman. Proceedings of Southwest State University. Series: History and Law. 2021;11(2):155-165. (In Russ.)